Metal Roofs vs. Shingles [Which Is Best for Your Home]

When your home is due for a roof replacement, there are several considerations that you need to make, one of which is the material. Your best options are typically metal and roofing shingles, but which of these two should you go for?


Remember that your roof is one of the most important parts of your house as it protects the home and your family from harsh weather elements and intrusions. It’s also a significant investment, so it’s only right that you make sure to get the correct material that would last for many years.


Both materials are excellent for residential roofing, but one may be the better choice for you. To help you decide, here are some of the things you need to know about metal roofs and shingles:




Metal roofs and shingles have finish options that will suit different housing styles. Shingle roofs do look traditional, but they are now made to look like tiles, wood shakes, or slate. The color palette is also quite wide, and they come in different finishes.


Metal roofing, on the other hand, has come a long way from looking like roofing for barns and sheds. Today, they are less rustic and even come in a variety of finishes and shades.


It’s likely that you’ll get the aesthetics that you like from either material, so the look shouldn’t be the deciding factor.




Metal roofing systems are generally more durable as they can withstand almost any harsh weather condition. That’s why they often come with a 30- to 50-year warranty, though most even go beyond that and last around 70 years. Yet, metal roofs aren't without their weaknesses because heavy branches and strong hail can affect metal roofs. If you have concerns about its vulnerability, it’s best to ask your roofing contractor about it.


Shingles’ lifespan is also considerably shorter due to their weaknesses. For instance, constant damp conditions can lead to the growth and spread of fungus and algae, while ice dams can lead to cracks. Depending on where you live and the climate in your area, shingle roofing may come with 15 years to 30 years of warranty.




Because metal roofing is made mostly from recycled materials and can be recycled after their use, they are considered the more sustainable option. They’re also more energy-efficient because they have reflective properties that block heat from entering the home.


Asphalt shingles, in comparison, need replacement more frequently. And since they are a petroleum-based product, it means they depend a lot on fossil fuels.




Upfront shingle roofs are much cheaper. Metal roofing costs significantly higher upon installation, although it offers savings in the long run as it lasts two to three times longer than shingle roofing. The installation of a metal roof is also costlier because it’s considered a more specialized task. If you are on a budget, consider roof shingles that are still an excellent choice and are available for a lower price point.




When deciding on the roofing type, make sure that you check the local building code for any requirements or limitations. It’s also a good idea to speak with roofing experts like Three Mountain Roofing’s professional roofers who can provide you with sound advice. This way, when you choose between roof shingles and metal roofs, you can be sure that you’re making an informed decision and not just a blind guess. In the end, this might be one of the biggest updates you’ll make for your home!


When you’re ready for your roof installation, Three Mountain Roofing is here to provide you with reliable services. We are one of the best roofers in Vermont that can provide you with a variety of roofing services, from simple repairs to whole roofing system replacements. Contact us today to learn more about how we can help!

Comments (0)

Leave a comment